The Absolute Sound Super Disc List TAS Harry Pearson Super LP List
Trumpeter Chet Baker's singing still provokes debate. Some love it, others wish he'd saved his singing for the shower. Here's a chance to make up your own mind by sampling some of the best singing of Baker's early career, when the voice was fresh, the ideas new.
We live in partisan times, we're told. Republicans and Democrats, Sox fans and Yankee fans, sushi lovers and those who need their fish cooked. So why not toss trumpeter Chet Baker's singing into the mix?
As Gerald Heard's liner notes point out, it's difficult to decide whether Chet Baker was a trumpet player who sang or a singer who played trumpet. When the 24-year-old California-based trumpeter started his vocal career in 1954, his singing was revolutionary; as delicate and clear as his trumpet playing, with a similarly bright and vibrato-free tone, Baker simply didn't sound like any previous jazz singer. His first vocal session, recorded in February 1954 and covering tracks seven through 14 of this disc, is so innocent-sounding it's like cub reporter Jimmy Olsen had started a new career as a jazz singer. The album's first six tracks, recorded in July 1956, are even more milk and cookies, thanks in no small part to syrupy material like Frank Loesser's 'I've Never Been in Love Before' and Donaldson/Kahn's drippy 'My Buddy.' Choices from the earlier session like 'My Funny Valentine' -- arguably the definitive version of this oft-recorded song -- and 'There Will Never Be Another You' work much, much better. The spacious musical setting, a simple trumpet and piano-bass-drums rhythm section, is perfect for Baker's low-key style. Despite the few faults of song selection, Chet Baker Sings is a classic of West Coast cool jazz.
1 That Old Feeling
2 My Funny Valentine
3 There Will Never Be Another You
4 The Thrill Is Gone
5 I Fall In Love Too Easily
6 Look For The Silver Lining
7 It's Always You
8 Like Someone In Love
9 My Ideal
10 I've Never Been In Love Before
11 My Buddy
12 But Not For Me
13 Time After Time
14 I Get Along Without You Very Well